Thursday, April 10, 2014

KNIFE CONTROL: WE NEED IT NOW




MASS SLASHING SPREE AT

SUBURBAN PITTSBURGH HIGH SCHOOL
Alex Hribal, the suspect in the stabbings at the Franklin Regional High School
 is taken from a district magistrate after he was arraigned on charges in the attack
 on Wednesday, April 9, 2014 in Export, Pa. (Keith Srakocic /AP)


TAGS: PITTSBURGH AREA HIGH SCHOOL STABBING, 21 HS STUDENTS
INJURED, MASS CAUSALTY EVENTS, KNIFE CONTROL,
CYNICAL SATORICAL OBSERVATIONS,
PUBLIC EDUCATION, EDUCATION INEQUALITIES,
JAILS, PRISONS, PENITENTERIES AS MENTAL HEALTH FACILITIES
(PLEASE READ ALL THE WAY THRU TO THE END)


(Thursday April 10, 2014, Pittsburgh, PA)  In the wake of a slashing spree yesterday at the High School in Murrysville
that left 21 students and a security guard with varying degrees of slash and stab wounds local, state and federal leaders are calling for more “knife control” legislation.  As the small town of Murrysville just north of Pittsburgh was coming to terms with the shocking events of yesterday some parents and officials were demanding that the issue of knife control to be addressed as a serious threat.  “There are far too many knives in our society.  People are very careless with their knives.  Some knives like penknives, Boy Scout knives or pocket knives are not as dangerous as kitchen knives, hunting knives, survival knives, carving knives, boning knives, sabers, daggers, swords, machetes, and some of the larger bladed implements that are out there”, said a man who would only identify himself as Stanley for fear that he might become a target for a stabbing or slashing if his identity was revealed.  Others in the community and here in Pittsburg as well echoed Stanley’s opinion.

In Washington, DC the Democratic Senator and Majority Leader hapless Harry Reid went to the Senate floor late yesterday afternoon and made an impassioned plea that “We all wake up to the fact of knife violence.  We should not need to be reminded about this country’s knife problem whenever a mass attack such as we witnessed today in a suburban Pittsburgh High School occurs.  We should be dealing with making this less of a knife culture all the time”.  Democrats have long been advocating for increasingly stricter knife control laws.  The Republicans, on the other side of the political divide, are very knife friendly and received staunch support and financial donations from the National Knife Association (NKA).

NKA Chairman Dwayne La Sagna made a statement at a hastily called press conference at the NKA headquarters in Washington, DC.  La Sagna commented that “We all recognize that what happened today in that Pennsylvania high school was tragic.  However, if we continue to just look at knives as the issue we will never reduce knife violence and knife deaths.  Over 99.9% of Americans own and use knives for the same purposes they have and their families have for generations.  The knife is no more a danger to our society in itself than is the crossbow.  We have ample knife control laws on the books and really need to look at the causative factors with knife violence such as the mental health of young offenders. Knife control is not the answer.  I own many knives and use them safely and responsibly for many purposes.  Maybe parents should be teaching their children more about knives and knife safety”.

Dr. Arlen D. Stutter, a clinical psychiatrist at the Western Pennsylvania Home for Lunatics, is a recognized authority on knife violence particularly among young offenders.  Dr. Stutter noted, “We live in a generally violent society.  As a people we tend to be more aggressive in manner and actions, more impulsive and have plenty of ways for us to safely, productively even, to express our aggressive urges and violent tendencies.  But the young people who commit these mass casualty slashing and stabbing crimes tend to be shy, introverted and, as is usually found in most of them, suffering from a more significant mental health issue ranging from simple idiopathic neurosis to schizophrenia and severe psychopathy.  These troubled youths need early intervention and most should be taking copious amounts of anti-psychotic drugs”. 

If the previous four paragraphs seem a bit ludicrous it is because they are.  They are meant to be.  If you were to go back and reread them and replace the word “gun” every time you saw the word “knife”, you would see just how ludicrous those assertions and statements are.  Make no mistake about it; yesterday’s events are horrifying to imagine.  That they transpired in a school, a place historically of safety, security and refuge makes them even more concerning. One might argue that had that 16 year old student with the knives been armed instead with guns we would be counted dead bodies rather than stab wounds and they are correct.  To a point.  Accessibility to and choice of weapon notwithstanding, a person bent on or driven to commit mass violence will achieve that goal one way or another. The point here is that the topic of "gun control" is asinine. The issue, if it were to be addressed, is "illegal" firearms out on the streets being peddled as easily as a rock of crack or a bag of weed.  Those are the guns that need control not the overwhelming majority of firearms owned and used by responsible people.

As Americans we have to accept certain aspects of our culture and society today that may be a little unsettling at first glance, need to be carefully considered when we debate matters of crime, criminality, mental health, gun ownership, gun control and our cultural obsession with violence.  We are a violent people; we always have been.  Our Country itself was born out of violence, practiced wholesale genocide on the Native American population, fought a brutal Civil War and has never known the true sacrifices that come with military conflict on our shores since the early years of the 1800’s.  The two “World Wars” were fought overseas as were all the other military conflicts in which we became engaged. Having not experienced war in our homeland, in our own cities, towns and communities we have become vicariously violent as spectators of violent sports, video games and more than jaded by the daily news. 

Some will argue that we do not have to “accept” these truths about our society, that we have the power to change it.  After all, we are not some banana republic or “third world nation”: we are American’s dam it, and we can change whatever needs changing.  Alas, if this were so.  We are who we are; we do what we can do.  We might dance around the fringes of an issue such as why many of our young children develop into stalkers, bullies, murderers, arsonists, drug abusers, antisocial personalities and exhibit all the various disorders defined in the textbook of mental disorders.  But, for all the fancy footwork and dancing, for all the studies, panels, experts, blue-ribbon commissions, peer reviewed papers and all the rest, we seem to wind up at the exact same point from which we began. 

For a country as big, diverse and disparate as ours with a multicultural, multiethnic composition, free markets, freedom of speech, religion and all the other traits that make our country what it is, it is a little surprising why we do not have more crime, why we don’t have more frequent mass casualty crimes committed.  We number over 400 million in population and are scattered over this part of the North American continent in big urban centers surrounded by rings suburban and exurban living.  We have smaller cities interspersed throughout rural sections in the continental 48 States and our Constitution, while a little strained and twisted, has served us well.  Our public education system and criminal justice system are profoundly dysfunctional and, if one were to believe that those two entities are not intimately related, they would be very much mistaken.  If as a society we cannot provide an equal education for all of our children regardless of any external factors then we are failing as a society.  When our jails, prisons and penitentiaries become the go-to warehousing place for the mentally ill among us we are falling short.

Our broad systemic failures in public education also pose a serious national security threat.  In a paper sponsored by the Council on Foreign Relations and co-authored by two former Secretaries of State, Henry Kissinger and Condoleezza Rice reported that an alarming number of applicants to enlist in the Armed Forces cannot even pass the basic competency tests for admission to the military.  In a similar study conducted by the RAND Corporation over 25% of potential enlistees were disqualified because they could not achieve a passing grade on that same basic skills test that Drs. Kissinger and Rice evaluated in their work.

Providing a basic education for every child in the country should be among the very top priorities of the federal government.  State and local politics, regional tendencies and any number of extraneous variables should not be impediments to attaining that goal.  Our educators interactions with our children may be the only positive interactions they have with an adult.  This is not about need or merit, nor is it about any of the other red herrings that politicians like to throw out into this debate.  This is a nation-wide problem and it needs to be addressed in a serious manner.

We do not intend to say or even remotely imply that lack of education, poverty, bad neighborhoods or whatever else can be tossed into the excuse pot are “valid” reasons for, or “causes” of violence in our society especially among our youth.  That is simply not the case.  Millions of Americans over generations and hundreds of years have lived in less than ideal circumstances and have gone on to be productive law abiding members of society.  We cannot perform some type of “Mass mental health evaluation” for every child or teenager in the country but, the more of them we can teach – actually get into a classroom and keep them there - the better off we will all be.  Having our youth as “students” allows for them to be casually observed and unofficially evaluated by their educators on a daily basis and it is that level of scrutiny, that noninvasive or confrontational observance that might help a teacher identifies a legitimately “troubled” student before they drop out and pick up a knife…or a gun.  Our public schools lose hundreds of students a month to the streets or town squares.  In some of our largest cities, the biggest urban school districts, the dropout rates are almost at 50%.  That should be unacceptable to every person in the country, to every voter, to every elected official be they members of a local school board or the President of the United States.

Until we assume the responsibility as a people to provide an equal education for every child we will continue our slow but sure backsliding and it will continue to get worse.










Copyright The Brooding Cynyx 2014 © All Rights Reserved

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hmmm....good segue from one issue into another and tying them neatly together. But knife violence and gun violence are two different things and I think that there is a gun culture in this country that is not only out of control, but somehow has come to see itself as the defender of all things American. It's a culture that thrives on violence and anger and fear. Tenn jus passed an open carry- no permits needed gun law. Explain to me how this is responsible gun ownership? Or responsible societal behavior? You nailed how big and complex our society is, but instead of us emphasizing the things we must do to make this big, complex society work, the gun culture emphasizes the things that make us dysfunctional, disguised as "freedom," "Liberty" and "constitutionality." Every man a John Wayne and every woman a Calamity Jane.

Someone made a meme that says, " If your first thought after Sandy Hook was, "OMG- they're coming to take our guns" your priorities as a human being suck. I'm going to say I agree with that. (Not "you" personally).

Education is a priority. No question. But the issue goes deeper than that- it goes to the heart of us as Americans, as a country, as social animals. When we whine that owning a gun is a right (who decided that? Odin? Zeus?) and not a responsibility we lost the battle to be an intelligent, productive, less violent society. TENN also, btw, took down the mandate safety class for a gun license, proving the smell of gunpowder does seriously kill brain cells.- dmj

Brooding Cynyc said...

Agree with you, Anonymous commentator, 100%. My argument might have bogged down somewhere between the knife/gun analogy. My intention was more to vent concern about how we as a nation intend to move forward while so much of the wider world seems to surpass us in the very same "values" we claim as our own.

As always, your comments are greatly appreciated.